Warm, classic sunroom overlooking a quiet lake through late-autumn trees in Sullivan County.

What a Sullivan County Asking Price Means to an Orange County Buyer

In the 12 months through October 2026, a single-family home in Sullivan County sold for an average of 92.3% of its original asking price. In Orange County over the same 12 months, the figure was 97.8%. Take a house first listed at $400,000. At Sullivan's rate it sells for about $369,200. At Orange's rate it sells for about $391,200. The two counties share a border, and those two numbers describe very different markets.

Here's the short version. Sullivan County is the one market around here where asking prices still give way. The reason is that many of its buyers don't have to buy. That room to negotiate is real, but the newest numbers show it getting smaller.

The Same Fall in Three Counties

These are the OneKey MLS single-family figures for the 12 months through October 2026, from the reports the Hudson Gateway Association of Realtors publishes each month. Months of supply comes from the New York State Association of Realtors Q3 2026 county report.

County Median price, 12 mo. through Oct. 2026 Change vs. prior 12 mo. Days on market % of original list received Months of supply, Q3 2026
Sullivan $350,000 down 4.8% 99 92.3% 9.5
Orange $490,000 up 3.2% 60 97.8% 5.0
Rockland $785,000 up 3.1% 46 99.3% 3.7

Sullivan is the only county in that group where the 12-month median went down. Its months of supply in the third quarter of 2026 was also higher than in Orange, Rockland, Putnam, Dutchess or Ulster. Ulster was at 6.1, Dutchess at 4.4, Putnam at 3.4, and New York State as a whole at 4.0. Months of supply estimates how long the current inventory would take to sell at the current pace of sales. Near 10 months, a buyer has time to wait. Near 4, a buyer doesn't.

Why Sullivan Behaves Like a Resort Market

"We're a resort market," Callicoon broker Tom Freda told the Sullivan County Democrat in March. That one line explains most of the table. In Orange and Rockland, many sales happen because someone has to move for a job, a growing family or a commute. In Sullivan, a big share of demand is optional. A weekend buyer who doesn't like the price can wait a season, or just keep renting a cabin. Sellers price for that buyer, and when that buyer holds back, listings sit.

The pandemic years show how much optional money can move this market. The paper reported how buyers came north in waves. "When Rockland and Orange got sold out, they moved into Sullivan," Lynne Freda said, and Tom Freda added, "We pretty much saw things double." The annual figures from Hudson Valley Pattern for Progress back that up. Sullivan's median rose from $144,900 in 2019 to $350,000 in 2025, a 141.5% increase over those six years. Closed sales went from 1,028 in 2019 to 1,367 in 2021, then fell to 806 in 2025.

So prices rose and stayed up, while the number of buyers willing to pay them went down. When fewer buyers face prices that stayed high, homes sit longer and sellers accept less.

Pattern for Progress released a study on November 13 that measures how far that optional demand reaches into the housing stock. Its report, Commercialization of Housing in the Mid-Hudson Valley, counted 1,292 entire-home Airbnb listings in Sullivan in 2025. That equals 4% of the county's housing stock, up from less than 1% in 2015. The study found that 32% of those listings had a host based in New York City. Orange County's figure was 1%.

The study found no evidence of large-scale single-family buying by major national institutional investors in the region. In Sullivan, corporate entities such as LLCs owned about 9% of 1-to-4-family parcels, and 91% of those owners had New York State mailing addresses. The study names Smallwood, in the Town of Bethel, as one place where county stakeholders described rental activity picking up in the mid-2010s and speeding up during and after the pandemic. Corporate ownership there tops 6%, which is more than 150 properties. In practice, the competing bidder on a Sullivan house is much more likely to be a weekender or a small local owner than a fund.

The Cushion Is Getting Thinner

In the third quarter of 2026, closed sales in Sullivan rose 13.8% from the same quarter in 2025, to 239. New listings fell 10%, to 441. Months of supply dropped from 10.5 to 9.5. More homes are selling while fewer new ones come on the market. Keep that up for a few more quarters and the surplus that gives buyers room today gets smaller.

The Freda interview points to one reason new listings are drying up. Owners who locked in mortgage rates of 2% to 3% don't want to give them up. "Those people will not get rid of that mortgage," Lynne Freda told the paper.

Supply also moved a lot within this year. The Sullivan County Democrat, citing state Realtor data, reported that months of supply was 5.8 in January 2026, much lower than the 9.5 recorded in the third quarter. At the end of October, 603 single-family homes were for sale in the county. That is close to the 607 on the market a year earlier, and those homes had been taking 84 days to sell in October. A buyer looking now has more choice than the January numbers suggested.

What Could Bring Buyers Back

What keeps optional demand alive in Sullivan is the reason people come up in the first place. In October 2025, Travel + Leisure named Callicoon and Livingston Manor among the best small towns in the Catskills, as the Sullivan County Democrat reported. The article pointed to their shops, inns, breweries, bakeries and the Callicoon farmers market.

The largest project in view is in Liberty. In July 2026, PPG Development submitted a multi-phase plan to redevelop the old Grossinger's resort, according to the River Reporter. The plan calls for a hotel of about 100 rooms, cottages, about 30 residential lots in the first phase and 145 more in later phases. When the paper reported it, the plan was headed to the Town of Liberty Planning Board. Treat it as a proposal, not a sure thing, when you think about prices near Liberty.

Reading a Sullivan Listing With Orange County Eyes

Orange County buyers are used to a market where the asking price is close to the final price. The county's 97.8% rate over the past year means an offer well under asking can lose the house. Bring that habit to Sullivan and you can end up paying more than you need to. Over the same 12 months, a typical Sullivan house took 99 days to go under contract and sold for about 92% of its first asking price.

Countywide averages hide a lot of variety from one home to the next. Tom Freda told the Sullivan County Democrat that realistically priced homes are still selling, even with fewer bidding wars than at the peak. A well-priced house in Callicoon in move-in condition and a cabin that has sat since June are two different negotiations. Before you write an offer, check the listing date, any price cuts, and how the house was used, whether as a full-time home or a rental. Those three things tell you more about how much room you have than the county average does.

Watch the October single-month figures with some care. Sullivan's October median was $349,500 on only 60 closed sales. With a sample that small, OneKey warns that percent changes can look extreme. The 12-month numbers are the better guide.

FAQ

Is Sullivan County a buyer's market right now? By supply, it leans that way. The county had 9.5 months of supply in the third quarter of 2026, nearly double Orange County's 5.0. Supply is falling, though, and was down from 10.5 a year earlier.

Have Sullivan prices dropped back to pre-pandemic levels? No. The 12-month median through October 2026 was $350,000. Pattern for Progress put the 2019 median at $144,900.

How does the price gap with Orange County look? In the 12 months through October 2026, Orange County's single-family median was $490,000 and Sullivan's was $350,000, a difference of $140,000.

If you're weighing a house in Orange County against a getaway on the Sullivan County side, a good offer looks different in each market. James J Cosenza can pull the listing history and recent nearby sales on the specific Sullivan house you're looking at, so your first offer is based on that house's numbers and not the county average. If you already own in Orange County and would sell to fund the move, start with a free home valuation so you know what you'll have to work with on both sides.

Work With James

His attention to detail, investigative and negotiating skills, and problem-solving are all essential traits in his real estate business. So is the work ethic that led to opening a successful business. He does strive to make every customer a customer for life, and still sets goals and does whatever it takes to achieve them.

Follow Me on Instagram