Traditional brick and white-clapboard home overlooking a bluestone terrace and broad autumn lawn.

Sugar Loaf Mountain Has Been Open for a Year. Just Not the Top.

Can you walk on Sugar Loaf Mountain yet? Part of it has been open to the public for a year, but the way in isn't from Kings Highway and the trails don't go to the summit.

On October 27, 2025, County Executive Steve Neuhaus opened 57.5 acres at 245 Laroe Road in the Town of Chester to the public. The county calls the land "part of the Sugar Loaf Mountain property acquisition." The rest of the mountain is being opened in stages. Access starts at the base, along a road that hikers were already using as a trail stop.

Why So Many People Still Think It's Closed

There's a simple reason for the confusion. The Orange County Land Trust's Sugar Loaf page still says the property is "privately-owned and public access is prohibited at this time." That wording comes from before the purchase.

Ownership has changed twice since then. The Land Trust bought the mountain from the Palmer family, its longtime owners, and then transferred it to Orange County. The county legislature approved $2.21 million for the acquisition costs, and the vote was 20-0, according to the Times Herald-Record. The same report gave the parcel's size as 309 acres. It also said the county's Department of Parks and Recreation had to plan trails and parking before the public could come in.

That planning produced the Laroe Road opening. So the Land Trust's notice still describes the mountain as private, and the county's release describes a public recreation area. Both are on the web right now. The county release is the more recent of the two.

What's Actually Open at 245 Laroe Road

The county lists these amenities:

  • Hiking and walking trails
  • A parking area
  • A picnic area with garbage cans
  • Two fishing ponds, catch and release only
  • Dogs allowed on leash
  • Open dawn to dusk

According to the opening release, the Parks Department handled planning, design and the first site work. Ongoing care includes regular mowing of the pathways. Expect mown paths through open ground, not a rocky climb.

The site still doesn't have a real name. The county said Neuhaus would announce a formal name later. For now it's the Orange County Recreation Area at 245 Laroe Road, Chester. The county's own facility page shortens that to "OC Recreation Area at Laroe Rd." Search the address, not the mountain.

Laroe Road Was Already a Trailhead

Before the county bought anything, Laroe Road was already a stop on the Highlands Trail.

The New York-New Jersey Trail Conference describes a route through Goosepond Mountain State Park that its volunteers rerouted off a risky road-walk in Chester. The rerouted section runs about 2 miles and is built for hikers and non-motorized bikes. Here's the route the Trail Conference lays out:

  1. Start at the parking lot on Bull Mill Road near the corner of Laroe Road.
  2. Follow the blue diamond Highlands Trail blazes past sycamores above the Trout Brook wetlands.
  3. Climb to an overlook of Sugar Loaf Mountain, then pass through red cedar outcrops down to Bull Mill Road.
  4. Cross the Seely Brook stepping stones and bog bridge, then head north toward Lazy Hill Road.
  5. Turn left over the restored Seely Brook bridge to the Laroe Road parking. That's about a 3-mile hike done as an out-and-back or with two cars.

If you turn right toward Route 17M instead, the hike stretches to about 5 miles. Along the way, an unmarked side loop called the Board Family Cemetery Trail leads to a bench above the Goosepond wetlands.

So the best-known view of Sugar Loaf Mountain on that trail is an overlook from Goosepond. The Laroe Road side has drawn hikers for years. The county's 57.5 acres add a second public stop on that road. The trail descriptions don't show the two sites connected by a marked path. Treat them as two separate outings close together. New York State Parks lists Goosepond as open year-round, dawn to dusk, with hiking and equestrian trails and a downloadable map. Both sites close at dusk, and dusk comes early in November. Plan for an afternoon start, not an after-work one.

What the County Has Said About Going Higher

The latest public word on what comes next is from June 2026 committee meetings of the Orange County Legislature.

On June 22, a legislator asked whether the Sugar Loaf Mountain trails would get a map or trail markers. Parks Commissioner Travis Ewald said the county would contract with the New York/New Jersey Trail Conference. The Conference would draw a sketch layout of the area and produce construction documents for "the lower loop," and county staff would start making improvements. Ewald said the county expects "probably next year" to have "that piece of property that they need for access," and then "do the same thing up there." That exchange is in the Physical Services Committee minutes.

The next day, the Ways and Means Committee minutes listed an equipment storage shed at the Laroe Road site among the projects in a $200,000 countywide capital line. That line covers small park structures and improvements. The shed shares that list with work at Winding Hills, Thomas Bull and the D&H Visitor Center. In other words, the Sugar Loaf site is now handled as a regular county park.

Here's where each piece stood as of those June minutes:

Piece of the mountain Where it stands Timing the county has given
57.5 acres at 245 Laroe Road Open, dawn to dusk Opened October 27, 2025
Marked "lower loop" Trail Conference layout and construction documents planned No date given
Storage shed at Laroe Road Listed in a 2026 capital line No date given
Access to the upper mountain Depends on getting a needed piece of property "Probably next year"

The Town of Chester's 2026 Comprehensive Plan, adopted July 8, 2026, describes the summit route. Citing the Land Trust, it says the trail would start at a parking lot still to be built off the Kings Highway Bypass and climb about 1.25 to 1.5 miles to the summit. The plan also backs trailheads, hiker parking and footpaths that would connect Goosepond Mountain State Park, the Sugar Loaf hamlet and the Highlands Trail.

The base opened first, from Laroe Road. The summit trail is planned from the Kings Highway side, behind a property step the county expects to take next year at the earliest. For now, the mountain is something you look at from Goosepond's overlook and walk around at its base.

Finish on Kings Highway

Laroe Road leads back toward the hamlet, and Kings Highway has three spots that are in business, based on their own sites:

  • Valkyrie Coffee Roasters runs a café at 1398 Kings Highway in Sugar Loaf. Its site doesn't post hours, so check the café page before you go.
  • Sugar Loaf Taphouse at 1368 Kings Hwy says it's "Open 7 Days a Week." Lunch and dinner end at 8 p.m. on the day its site shows, and the bar stays open later. Details are on the Taphouse site.
  • Cancun Inn at 1396 Kings Hwy is open 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sunday and Tuesday through Thursday, 11:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and closed Monday. Its events page lists Friday Night Karaoke.

A Saturday loop that fits November daylight: coffee at Valkyrie, the mown paths and ponds at 245 Laroe Road, the Highlands Trail out-and-back from Bull Mill Road to the Sugar Loaf Mountain overlook, then a late lunch on Kings Highway before dusk closes both parks.

If an afternoon on Laroe Road has you thinking about your own place in Chester, James J Cosenza can tell you where it stands in today's market. Request Your Free Home Valuation.

Work With James

His attention to detail, investigative and negotiating skills, and problem-solving are all essential traits in his real estate business. So is the work ethic that led to opening a successful business. He does strive to make every customer a customer for life, and still sets goals and does whatever it takes to achieve them.

Follow Me on Instagram