A warmly lit table for two beside a white-trimmed restaurant window, with autumn branches and a brick building softly visible outside.

Between Tappan and Sparkill, Every Night of the Week Now Has a Table

Two new restaurants opened on two Orangetown Main Streets this fall. Alma Kitchen & Bar was already open at 623 Main Street in Sparkill when Boozy Burbs reported it on October 1, and Lugo Steakhouse opened at 89 Main Street in Tappan on October 9. Both have octopus on the menu. Both start dinner around 4 p.m. on weekdays. Both are closed Mondays.

From Wednesday through Sunday, both serve dinner. The difference is at the edges of the week, and that matters more than the menus. Alma takes Tuesday, which Lugo doesn't. Lugo takes weekend afternoons, which Alma doesn't. Monday, which neither one covers, already belongs to the Old '76 House across from Tappan Reformed Church. Taken together, southern Orangetown now has a sit-down dinner option every night of the week, just not at the same place.

The Week at a Glance

Night Alma Kitchen & Bar, Sparkill Lugo Steakhouse, Tappan Old '76 House, Tappan
Monday Closed Closed Tie Dye Monday, about 7 to 10 p.m.
Tuesday 4 to 9 p.m. Closed
Wednesday 4 to 9 p.m. 4 to 10 p.m.
Thursday 4 to 9 p.m. 4 to 10 p.m.
Friday 4 to 10:30 p.m. 4 to 10 p.m.
Saturday 4 to 10:30 p.m. 12:30 to 10:30 p.m.
Sunday 4 to 9 p.m. 12:30 to 9:30 p.m. Special brunches Nov. 22 and Nov. 29

The hours come from each restaurant's own website, and new places often change their hours in the first few months. Call before making a special trip. Alma is at 845-613-7878, and Lugo takes reservations by phone at 845-613-8140.

Sparkill Has Tuesday to Itself

Alma is the only one of the two new restaurants that serves on Tuesday, so start there. Boozy Burbs reported that owner Brenda Ortiz grew up in Rockland County and runs the bar program herself as Alma's mixologist. The kitchen is led by chef Tatiana Bautista, who has cooked in several Rockland kitchens. The Rockland/Westchester Journal News summed it up as "inventive cocktails and New American cuisine."

The menu mixes starters like tuna wontons and Spanish octopus with entrées like churrasco, branzino and linguini mare. The house cocktails include the Alma-Rita and La Ultima Palabra.

Tuesday, December 1 is the first night that Tuesday-only access really pays off. That evening the Tappan, Blauvelt, Orangeburg and Palisades libraries host the South Orangetown Holiday Bash at the Tappan Fire Department, 123 Washington Street, from 5 to 6:30 p.m. It's drop-in, with crafts, cocoa and a visit from Santa, and no registration is required. The Bash wraps up at 6:30. Lugo is closed that night, and Alma serves until 9.

Tappan Has the Weekend Afternoon

Lugo flips that pattern. It's closed early in the week but opens at 12:30 p.m. on Saturdays and Sundays, three and a half hours before Alma. According to the Journal News, the restaurant took over the space Il Portico used to occupy and is a new concept from Benny Castro, who owns Basque Tapas in Piermont and Tarrytown.

The menu is built for groups. The big cuts come sliced for the table, and the prices make the most sense split several ways:

  • Porter House, 38 oz., $80
  • Chuletón de Buey, a 34 oz. bone-in ribeye, $84
  • Tomahawk, 40 oz., $140
  • Filet Mignon Asado, sliced for four to five, $175

Compare the porterhouse and the tomahawk. The tomahawk is only 2 ounces heavier, but it costs $60 more. That premium buys the presentation, not more steak. For a table of four or five, the sliced filet works out to roughly $35 to $44 a person before sides and drinks.

The small plates are where Lugo and Alma overlap. Lugo's Pulpo a la Brasa is a Galician-style octopus at $25. There are also Gambones al Ajillo, jumbo shrimp in garlic sauce, at $22, and six East Coast oysters for $18. The wine list leans Spanish, from a $14 Cava Sangría and an $18 glass of Cinco Islas albariño up to a 2016 Vega Sicilia Único at $850.

The 12:30 opening fits the first weekend of December nicely. On Saturday, December 5, St. Thomas Aquinas College's Hospitality Management students host the Winter Wonderland Family Festival on the front lawn of the campus at 125 Route 340 in Sparkill, from noon to 4 p.m. By the time the festival winds down, both new restaurants are open. That Saturday is one of the few times the two schedules make a Sparkill afternoon and a Tappan or Sparkill dinner easy to string together.

Sunday, December 6 starts earlier. The Town of Orangetown Parks and Recreation's 35th Annual Santa Claus 5K starts and finishes at Veterans Memorial Park in Orangeburg at 10:30 a.m., according to the town's Fall 2026 recreation brochure. That afternoon, from 2 to 4 p.m., the Dennis P. McHugh Piermont Public Library opens its Annual Holiday Gift of Art Show with a reception at 25 Fly Wheel Park. The art is for sale, and the proceeds support the library. Lugo is already serving during the reception, and both restaurants are open for dinner once it ends.

Two November Sundays Across From the Church

Lugo's Sunday afternoon hours overlap with something Tappan already had. The Old '76 House at 110 Main Street has two themed Sunday brunches on its happenings page this month:

  1. Brunch with George Washington, Sunday, November 22. George and Martha Washington join the buffet brunch, which runs 11:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. The price is $39.95 a person, with beverages, tax and gratuity extra.
  2. In the Shadows of the Gallows, Sunday, November 29. Brunch runs from 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., and then guests cross the street to Tappan Reformed Church. There, a 2:30 p.m. reenactment puts Joshua Hett Smith on trial for his part in Benedict Arnold's meeting with Major John André. Brunch and the reenactment together cost $39.95 a person. The reenactment alone is $25, cash only.

Both events take reservations at 845-359-5476. On both Sundays, Lugo opens at 89 Main Street an hour after brunch starts at number 110. Tappan's Main Street now has two restaurants serving on Sunday afternoons.

Monday Stays at the '76 House

Monday is the night both new restaurants skip, and the Old '76 House already fills it. Every Monday from "7ish to 10ish," Johnny Markowski of Riders of the Purple Sage and his crew play the Grateful Dead for Tie Dye Monday, with food, drinks, vendors and dancing. Reservations go through the same 845-359-5476 number.

December 7 is a Monday that's worth planning. The Village of Piermont lists a Menorah Lighting Ceremony in front of Village Hall at 478 Piermont Avenue from 6 to 7 p.m. When the ceremony ends, Alma and Lugo are both closed for the night, and the music at the '76 House is just getting started.

When Nobody Wants to Go Out

Some nights the best option is food you bring home. Old World Food Market, which started in Nyack, has opened a second store next to CVS in the Orangeburg Shopping Center. Boozy Burbs reported that the space was fully renovated before it opened. The store sells prepared meals, hot food to go, sandwiches, salads, baked goods and gourmet groceries, and it also offers delivery and catering. The market's contact page lists the Orangeburg address alongside the Nyack store.

New restaurants opening on Sparkill's and Tappan's Main Streets show how much activity there is in southern Orangetown right now, and buyers notice that kind of activity. If you live in Tappan, Sparkill, Piermont or Orangeburg and want to know where your home stands this winter, James J Cosenza can give you a straight answer backed by real local numbers. Request your free home valuation, and Jimmy will walk you through it.

Work With James

His attention to detail, investigative and negotiating skills, and problem-solving are all essential traits in his real estate business. So is the work ethic that led to opening a successful business. He does strive to make every customer a customer for life, and still sets goals and does whatever it takes to achieve them.

Follow Me on Instagram